Getting started

How to choose the right pickleball paddle

The short answer

Identify your priorities first. For many players the most important are shape, swing weight, power level, feel and durability. Once you know your preferences there, you can rule out most paddles and focus on the ones that genuinely fit your game.

Some links are affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details.

An orange silhouette holding their head in confusion, surrounded by question marks, behind a row of different pickleball paddles

Overview

The biggest challenge today is not finding a good pickleball paddle. There are hundreds of quality options available. The real challenge is finding the paddle that best matches your playing style, preferences, and priorities.

Rather than chasing every new release, focus on a small set of criteria that matter most to you. This can dramatically reduce the number of paddles worth considering.

Primary factors

These are generally the most important factors when selecting a paddle.

1. Paddle shape

There are three main paddle shapes:

Elongated

  • Longest reach
  • Typically longer handles for two-handed backhands
  • Popular with former tennis players
  • Usually less manoeuvrable at the net
  • Often have higher swing weights

Widebody

  • Largest sweet spot
  • Most manoeuvrable shape
  • Fastest at the kitchen line
  • Less reach than elongated paddles

Hybrid

  • Combines elements of both elongated and widebody designs
  • Provides a balance of reach, manoeuvrability, and sweet spot size
  • The most versatile option for many players

Recommendation: If you’re new to racket sports, a widebody is a good shape because it’s very forgiving. If you’re coming from tennis or another racket sport, go elongated: tennis players almost always prefer one. A hybrid is the best of both worlds for players who want manoeuvrability at the kitchen and hit fewer off-centre shots. Choose the shape closest to what you’re already comfortable using unless you specifically want to experiment.

My paddle shapes guide shows the three side by side.

2. Swing weight

Swing weight is one of the most important specifications because it determines how heavy a paddle feels during play.

Unlike static weight, swing weight reflects how the weight is distributed throughout the paddle.

Lower swing weight (under ~112)

  • Easier to manoeuvre
  • Faster hand speed
  • Better for quick exchanges at the net

Higher swing weight (118+)

  • More stability and plough-through
  • Generates easier power
  • Feels more familiar to many tennis players

Recommendation: If you dislike heavy-feeling paddles, stay below 112. If you come from tennis or prefer stability and power, consider higher swing weights.

3. Power level

Most paddles fall into one of three categories:

Control

  • Greater forgiveness
  • Easier resets and dinks
  • Helps reduce unforced errors

All-Court

  • Balanced blend of control and power
  • Suitable for most players
  • Safest option for those still learning their preferences

Power

  • More aggressive drives and counters
  • Easier put-aways
  • Less forgiving on touch shots

Recommendation: If you’re unsure where to start, choose an all-court paddle.

4. Paddle feel

Paddle feel is highly subjective but can strongly affect whether you enjoy using a paddle.

Soft & dense

  • Absorbs pace well
  • More controlled feeling
  • Quieter impact
  • Often preferred by control-oriented players

Stiff & hollow

  • More pop and feedback
  • Louder impact
  • More aggressive feel
  • Often preferred by power-oriented players

Recommendation: Try as many paddles as possible to identify what feels best to you. Feel becomes more important once you’ve used multiple paddles and developed preferences.

5. Durability (Gen 3 vs Gen 4)

The market is currently dominated by two core constructions:

Gen 3

  • Polymer core with foam around the perimeter
  • Often preferred for feedback and connection to the ball
  • Can experience “core crushing” over time, making the paddle illegal for tournament use

Gen 4 (full foam core)

  • Foam throughout the core
  • More durable
  • No core-crushing concerns
  • Some players feel they provide less direct feedback

Recommendation: If you don’t have a strong preference, a modern foam-core (Gen 4) paddle is usually the safest choice due to improved durability.

Secondary factors

These matter, but most players are willing to compromise on them if the primary factors are right.

6. Budget

Good paddles typically range from £70-£250+ ($90-$300+).

Key takeaway:

  • Excellent paddles exist around the £80/$100 mark.
  • Spending more money does not automatically improve performance.
  • Many sub-$100 paddles are fully competitive at advanced levels.
  • Choose a budget first to immediately narrow down your options.

My guide on how much to spend goes into more detail.

7. Spin

Spin is often overemphasised.

Most modern quality paddles produce very similar spin levels due to certification limits and current paddle technology.

Recommendation: As long as you’re buying a reputable paddle, spin should not be a major deciding factor.

8. Sweet spot

Sweet spots have improved dramatically across the industry.

Modern paddles generally provide:

  • Large forgiving hitting areas
  • Consistent performance
  • Few truly poor sweet spots

Recommendation: Unless reviewers consistently mention a bad sweet spot, it’s usually not something worth worrying about.

9. Paddle thickness

Paddle cores range from 10 mm to 20 mm, but the market has largely standardised around 16 mm.

16 mm

  • Dominates the modern market
  • Common among today’s foam-core paddles
  • Generally easier to use
  • Larger sweet spots
  • Better all-round option

14 mm

  • Less common today
  • More associated with older paddle generations, including many Gen 3 designs
  • Usually quicker in the hand
  • Typically offers a smaller sweet spot
  • Can require added weight to reach peak performance

Recommendation: For most players, start with 16 mm. It has effectively become the market standard, especially as manufacturers have moved towards foam-core designs.

10. Handle length

Handle length affects comfort and backhand style.

Longer handles (5.5”+)

  • Better for two-handed backhands
  • Popular with tennis players

Shorter handles (5.25” and below)

  • Suitable for one-handed players
  • Preferred by some players with table tennis backgrounds

Recommendation: Anything between 5.25” and 5.5” is a safe choice if you’re unsure.

11. Grip size

Grip size is largely personal preference and generally matters less than it once did because:

  • Most paddles fall within a very similar grip-size range.
  • Players frequently customise grips using overgrips.
  • Small adjustments are easy and inexpensive to make.

Common sizes:

  • 4 1/8” for smaller hands
  • 4 1/4” for larger hands

Recommendation: Choose what feels comfortable, but don’t overthink grip size since it can be easily adjusted.

12. Certification

For the vast majority of players:

USAP certified

  • Accepted almost everywhere
  • Suitable for recreational and most tournament play

UPA certified

  • Used heavily in professional play
  • Some paddles feature more aggressive surfaces

Dual certified

  • Approved by both organisations

Recommendation: If you’re an amateur player, simply buying a USAP-certified paddle is enough in nearly all situations.

Final takeaway

Instead of following paddle hype or constantly buying the latest release, identify your priorities first.

For many players, the most important characteristics are:

  • Shape
  • Swing weight
  • Power level
  • Feel
  • Durability

Once you know your preferences in these areas, you can eliminate the vast majority of paddles from consideration and focus only on models that genuinely fit your game.

Remember: a new paddle launching every week does not make your current paddle obsolete.

Not sure which shape suits you? Try the shape quiz. It takes about a minute.

Quick questions

Which paddle shape should I choose?

If you're new to racket sports, a widebody is a good shape because it's very forgiving. If you're coming from tennis or another racket sport, go elongated. A hybrid is the best of both worlds for players who want manoeuvrability at the kitchen and hit fewer off-centre shots.

Should I get a control or power paddle?

If you're unsure where to start, choose an all-court paddle. It's a balanced blend of control and power, and the safest option while you're still learning your preferences.

How much should I spend on a pickleball paddle?

Good paddles typically range from £70-£250+ ($90-$300+). Excellent paddles exist around the £80/$100 mark, and spending more money does not automatically improve performance.

Does grip size matter?

Not much. Most paddles fall within a very similar grip-size range, and you can easily adjust it with an overgrip. Choose what feels comfortable and don't overthink it.

Keep reading