How I rate paddles

Short version: the letter is the 418 Pickle rating. The bars and the power, pop and spin numbers are measured in a lab. Grit durability tells you how well the face keeps its spin.

Methodology

How I test paddles

When I test a paddle myself, it goes through the same five steps.

The 418 Pickle rating blends that on-court testing with the measured numbers and the views of reviewers and players I trust.

  • Measured specs. Weight, swing weight, twist weight, power, pop and spin come from the 418 Pickle database of measured numbers, not from the brand's spec sheet.
  • Break-in. About 10 minutes of drives, dinks, drops and resets first, so the face settles before I judge it.
  • Power and spin. Drives, topspin and serves, hit with a drilling partner or a ball machine.
  • Kitchen touch and control. Dinks, third-shot drops and resets, to judge dwell, softness and how forgiving it is on mishits.
  • Transition and hand speed. Quick mid-court exchanges, where shape and twist weight separate the great paddles from the average ones.

1. The 418 Pickle rating (the letter)

Each rating brings together three things:

  • My own play. Paddles I've played myself, on court, in real games.
  • Trusted reviewers. What experienced, independent reviewers say after testing the same paddle.
  • The player community. What everyday players report in groups such as Discord communities: how a paddle holds up, and who it suits.

I weigh all of that up and give each paddle one letter:

  • 418 Pickle rating: tier S Outstanding. One of the best around.
  • 418 Pickle rating: tier A Excellent. Easy to recommend.
  • 418 Pickle rating: tier B Good. Worth buying if it suits you.
  • 418 Pickle rating: tier C OK. There are better choices for most people.
  • 418 Pickle rating: tier D Hard to recommend.

S tier needs two things: a durable grit that keeps its spin, and top performance. A paddle that plays brilliantly but loses its grit quickly can be A, not S.

Sometimes I add a score out of 10 as well, for example 418 Pickle rating: tier A, 8.5 out of 10.

Paddles I wouldn't recommend at all aren't listed. Paddles I haven't rated yet stay off the site until I have. I don't fill the gap with a computer-made letter.

2. Power and Control (the two bars)

These come from measured numbers, not from the brands. They're facts, not opinions, so you can compare paddles fairly. The tests measure how fast the ball comes off the paddle (power and pop), how steady the paddle is when you miss the middle (twist weight) and how heavy it feels to swing (swing weight).

All-Court+Balanced, leaning towards power.

Power66
Control64
  • Power (0 to 100) mixes the power and pop speeds shown in section 3. Higher means the ball comes off faster.
  • Control (0 to 100) mixes twist weight and swing weight. Higher means steadier on mishits and quicker in your hand, which usually makes a paddle easier to control.
  • Both scores compare each paddle with a large group of tested paddles, on the same scale as the power and pop speeds. On this site Power mostly runs from about 55 to 80 and Control from about 35 to 85.
  • If a paddle hasn't had the tests a score needs, I leave that bar out rather than guess.

Paddle type

The Power score also gives each paddle a simple type:

TypeWhat it means
ControlSoft and steady. Easy to place, with less pace.
Control+Mostly control, with a bit more pop.
All-CourtA balance of power and control.
All-Court+Balanced, leaning towards power.
PowerHits hard. Needs a softer touch at the net.
Power+Lots of pace. The hardest type to keep soft.

New players usually get on best with Control or All-Court paddles.

3. Power, Pop and Spin

Each shape shows three measured numbers near its rating:

  • Power (mph): how fast the ball leaves the paddle on a full swing, like a serve or drive.
  • Pop (mph): how fast it leaves on a short punch, like a volley at the net.
  • Spin (rpm): how fast the face makes the ball spin. More spin helps shots dip and curve.

Most of these numbers come from one main test rig, so they compare fairly. For a few shapes that rig hasn't tested, I use one other independent lab: its ball speeds come out within about half a mph of the main rig, and its spin readings usually run a little lower. Next to each number, Low, Medium or High shows where the paddle sits on the main rig's scale (bottom, middle or top third). For Spin, the top 10% are rated Very high. If neither lab has tested a shape, I leave these numbers out.

4. Grit durability

Textured faces wear smoother as you play, and spin drops with them. The grit durability rating groups faces by how much of their texture they keep after a heavy wear test:

  • Tier 1 – Excellent: keeps 95% or more.
  • Tier 2 – Very good: keeps 90 to 94%.
  • Tier 3 – Good: keeps 85 to 89%.
  • Tier 4 – Fair: keeps less than 85%, close to a plain carbon face.

Standard peel-ply faces have no durable grit. Their spin is measured new, and they typically lose around 20% of it after 10–20 games.

5. How I pick my top picks

The top picks on the home page, the "Recommended" order in the catalogue and the shape quiz results all use one score:

  • 50% the 418 Pickle rating. S, A, B, C and D count as 100, 85, 70, 55 and 40 points (averaged with the score out of 10 when there is one).
  • 25% beginner fit. How forgiving and easy to control it is in the lab.
  • 15% value. Cheaper paddles score higher.
  • 10% lab results. The Power and Control bars together.

If a part is missing, its weight is shared among the others.

6. Reviewer scores

On some paddle pages you'll see a reviewer score out of 100, under "What reviewers say". This is how it works:

  • It's a simple average. I take the score from each review of that paddle that gave one and average them, to one decimal place. Every scored review counts the same. If one reviewer has reviewed two versions of the same paddle, I may count them once, at the average of the two; the card says so.
  • Where each score comes from. If the reviewer gave a number, I use their score. Where a reviewer gives no number, I score their closing verdict on a fixed scale, and average that with a points score from their pros and cons: the card calls this a "418 Pickle reading". Each review card says which kind of score it is. Some reviews, often videos, don't give an overall score at all: I still show what they said, but they're not in the average, and the card says "No score".
  • Three scored reviews minimum. I only show a reviewer score once at least 3 reviews with a score are in. Until then the page says "Not enough scored reviews yet", and you can still read every review.
  • Plain-word bands: Standout 85 and up, Strong 80 to 84.9, Solid 70 to 79.9, Mixed under 70.
  • Common pros and cons are the points that come up with two or more reviewers, in their own words. Quotes are word for word from the review.
  • I name each reviewer and the month of the review. I don't link to reviews or videos.

My grade is separate. The 418 Pickle rating (the letter, section 1) is my own verdict and sits next to the reviewer score, never mixed into it. The reviewer score is only the average of the reviews: it isn't fed into my letter as a number, and it doesn't change the bars or the order I list paddles in.

What I don't do

  • I don't invent numbers. If I don't have one, I don't show it.
  • Affiliate links and brand partnerships never change a rating, a bar or the order I list paddles in.